By Coach Atwood
Have you ever been at a youth basketball game, and heard a frustrated voice in the stands repeatedly yelling, “run a play, run a play” in a sort of, what’s-wrong-with-you tone of voice? I used to feel pressure to conform to that voice. The implication was that teaching a set offense was something that I had to do, or I was failing. But there is no kind of team offense that is effective unless the players can consistently make layups and wide open shots. At the youth ages, those 20 minutes of valuable practice time spent teaching the cuts and screens of a flex offense are probably better spent learning how to shoot and make layups, because plays don’t make baskets, players with skills do. A plays is supposed to help get players good looks at the basket, but the kids have to possess the ability to score or a set offense is a waste. I believe this is generally true no matter the age of the players. There’s a way to measure the effectiveness of your offense. Look at the game video and count how many baskets you get from your team actually running a play correctly. Then count how many baskets you get off put backs, busted plays, steals, fast breaks, etc. If your team is spending significant practice time working on a set plays, or continuity offense, and then only making a few baskets a game despite running it over and over, is that good coaching? I’m not really sure, but I’m leaning toward no.
Someone once said, “Don’t confuse activity with progress.” That principle can apply to practicing. It’s easy to look busy and appear competent by running some organized drills. Organization implies competence. I look back on my first season and that’s what I was really doing, and I didn’t realize that. I was going thru the motions of organized activity, but there wasn’t a whole lot of teaching actually happening. When I put them into a lay up line, my instruction and attention was just as concerned with getting the mechanics of the drill right as with the actual skill. I was concerned with their form, but unconcerned at first that they were only going half speed and no one was guarding them. In my first season coaching middle school kids, the majority of the kids came to me with beginner skills- poor shot form, poor ball handling skills, and the inability to make layups with any consistency. I had two weeks to prepare them to compete in games.
While it’s true that any amount of time spent practicing and playing will improve skills, the point of a structured practice session is to make the best use of limited time to prepare a team to play games. The old coaching saying goes, “Teams are made in the season. Players are made in the off season.” There is a lot of pressure on a coach to prepare his team to play. You have to come up with the best plan you can to compete with the talent and skill available. When I was a kid growing up in a small town, there weren’t any leagues for 7, 8, 9, and10 year olds. We played outside on pavement. We learned the essential offensive skills from countless hours of small sided games. Play to 11, winner’s outs, gotta win by 2, call your own fouls. That’s where we learned to handle the ball and break a defender down. That’s where we learned to create space to get a shot off, and finish a layup with someone hanging off of us. Nowadays most of the kids come into our youth programs without those strong individual skills. And we make them run offense anyway, because maybe 6-8 of them have the athletic ability and/or skill to make it work, and there’s that guy in the stands yelling, “Run a play!” I believe that often times, running plays just serves to make our games look organized in the same sense that running drills can serve to make our practices look organized. And the coach can respond after a loss that, “They didn’t run the offense right.” But are they ready to run plays? Do they have the fundamental skills to make an offense work?
In Brian McCormick’s book, Cross Over The New Model of Youth Basketball Development, McCormick makes a strong case for examining and making changes in how we prepare youth to play the game. McCormick notes the demise of “free play,” and that basketball, and indeed today’s youth’s lives are generally more structured than past generations were. Basketball is an activity my generation played in parks, school yards and driveways. There were no grown ups there with us organizing, creating structure, holding down creativity and fun. Nowadays basketball is something done from 4:00 to 5:30 and virtually every moment of it is structured. McCormick believes that coaches tend to “over-coach,” that the influence of adults has made it about competing, winning games and tournaments. He believes the USA youth basketball development model is essentially broken; that it short changes long term athletic development for short term gains (win today). He calls this the “peak by Friday” mind set. He believes we need to find ways to return the game to the kids, and that at the youth level we need to focus on teaching players to play, not on preparing teams to win. Yes basketball is a team game, and yes even the kids want to win. But this much we know for sure- confident players play well, and good teams are made up of confident players. I say teaching skills that lead to confidence is far more critical than putting in “passing game,” and a zone offense.